- In 2009, Stacey Castor was convicted of fatally poisoning her husband, David Castor, with antifreeze.
- Castor is suspected to have killed her first husband, Michael Wallace, utilizing the same method, and she or he tried to poison her older daughter, Ashley Wallace, with crushed tablets and vodka.
- The brand new Lifetime Movie Poisoned Love: The Stacey Castor Story premieres on February 1 at eight p.m. ET and stars Nia Vardalos (My Large Fats Greek Wedding) as Castor.
Just like the Golden State Killer and the BTK Killer, Stacey Castor is among the rank of criminals higher recognized by her nickname. They name her the Black Widow. And on February 1, Lifetime will air Poisoned Love: The Stacey Castor Story, a fictionalized account of the spine-chilling deeds that made Castor infamous.
In 2009, Castor was convicted of murdering her second husband, David Castor, trying to homicide her daughter, Ashley Wallace, and making an attempt to forge her second husband’s will, which left his $300,000 property to her. Castor was sentenced to 51 years in jail—and that is simply the beginning of the story.
Starring My Large Fats Greek Wedding’s Nia Vardalos as Castor, Poisoned Love is a testomony to appearances being deceiving—as a result of for some time there, Castor had everybody in her Weedsport, New York community fooled of her innocence, together with her two daughters.
Poisoned Love is a part of Lifetime’s winter 2020 “Ripped From the Headlines” slate, a set of 5 movies that reenact current and shocking true crimes, just like the Kamiyah Mobley kidnapping case. This is what you’ll want to learn about Castor, who maintained her innocence till her death in 2016.
Who’s Stacey Castor?
To her Weedsport, New York community, Castor was an extremely resilient single mother who endured the next: the sudden death of her first husband, Michael Wallace, in 2000; the lack of her second husband, David Castor (Mike Dupod in Poisoned Love), in 2005; and the tried suicide of her daughter, Ashley Wallace (performed by Chanelle Peloso), in 2007.
In actuality, Castor had orchestrated their poisonings. Castor poisoned each of her husbands with antifreeze, and tried to kill her daughter with a mixture of vodka and crushed tablets. Fortunately, Ashley was rushed to the hospital and survived.
Even studying the grotesque information of Castor’s deeds, it is completely doable to be fooled by Castor in Poisoned Love—and that is completely because of the intelligent casting of Nia Vardalos. Nearly twenty years after her indie Movie My Large Fats Greek Wedding grew to become a sensation, Vardalos stays surrounded by an orb of indeniable affection. She’s the right individual to play Castor, a lady who wielded her likability as a weapon and a defend.
” that likable factor you do? Try this!” Vardalos recalled director Jim Donovan telling her, throughout an interview with Construct. Vardalos was instructed to play the character as if she had been harmless—and it really works.
How did Stacey Castor get caught?
Castor nearly acquired away with it. At first, David Castor’s death in 2005 was deemed a suicide. In an interview with police, Castor claimed David had been depressed because of the current lack of his father, in line with ABC Information.
However Detective Dominick Spinelli of the Onondaga County Sheriff’s division was uncertain of this story for a variety of causes. To start with, detectives found Castor’s fingerprints and traces of antifreeze on a turkey baster within the trash can.
Then, Spinelli noticed similarities between David’s death and Wallace’s, Castor’s first husband. Again in 2000, medical doctors decided Wallace had died of a coronary heart assault. However after police exhumed Wallace’s physique in September 2007, an autopsy found traces of antifreeze crystals in his physique.
“I knew at that time we had a double murder and Stacey Castor in all probability killed each her husbands,” Spinelli advised ABC Information. Ingesting, it needs to be famous, results in a “sluggish and agonizing and horrific” death, in line with prosector for one more antifreeze poisoning case (that one concerned a spiked margarita).
Two days after Wallace’s physique was exhumed, Castor was introduced in for questioning.
Sensing the partitions closing in on her, Castor tried to border her elder daughter, Ashley, in line with prosectors. Throughout an “early” celebration of Ashley’s 21st birthday, Castor gave her a cocktail of vodka spiked with tablets. The next morning, Bree Wallace found her older sister handed out next to a 750-word letter confessing to the murders of Michael and David.
On the morning of September 14, 2007, Ashley was rushed to the hospital and was “15 minutes from death,” in line with Onondaga County District Lawyer William Fitzpatrick, in an interview with ABC Information. When Ashley wakened, she denied being concerned with the murders. Spinelli believed her, too, as a result of the letter misspelled antifreeze as “antifree,” a mistake Castor all the time made when the saying phrase.